Critiques of Evangelicalism

I’m convinced that no matter what we believe and what group we are part of around those beliefs we have an obligation to review and test our beliefs and practices within that.

Whatever form of church community we find that supports what we now believe, we should always show our true value of that by testing and probing it, lest we make the same mistakes that we think we have avoided of others.

Over the years as part of my emerging church journey, I have a collection of books, that address specifically the beliefs and practices of evangelicals. I’m not talking about generic emerging church books, that too often set up evangelicals as the bogey/straw man, but books that have good research models other than personal preference, and that explore real information and theology.

Here is my list, that I found critical, and helpful, and at times sobering, and at others hopeful. What have you read that has done the same for you that I have missed?

1. Reinventing English Evangelicalism, 1966-2001: This book by Rob Warner, is about to be re-printed, and I just got a copy from Paternoster.

It is the most comprehensive theological and sociological overview of UK evangelicalism, that I have come across. Rob Warner was for so long, so involved with most people on the evangelical scene, and this is his PhD research in book form. It also reminded me of how different the UK is to the US when it comes to evangelicalism.

If you really want to understand UK evangelicals, this is a must have and read book.

2. What Christians Really Believe: This small book by Stanley Grenz was one of the first I read 10 years ago at the start of my questioning of evangelical beliefs and practices.

3. The Post-Evangelical & The Post-Evangelical Debate: Two small and easy to read books that gave an inside look, more at the culture and sociology of evangelicals in the UK, and why many were describing themselves as such. In my excitement I registered the domain postevangelical.org, but have since let it lapse.

4. The Re-making of Evangelical Theology: This book by Gary Dorrien, is still one of my favourites. If you want a theological critique of evagelical theology, this is a must have/read.

5. The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind: By Mark A. Knoll, a seminal and much referenced book. Mostly US focused, but a great theological critique of evangelical spirituality and practice.

6. Scandal of the Evangelical Consciousness: By Ronald Sider, with a bit of a recurring theme for the title. An exploration of how believing and saying Jesus is Lord has led to little difference in daily life habits from those who don’t.

6. The Fall of the Evangelical Nation: By Christine Wicker. This one just came through my post box today. An overview of the decline of evangelicalism in the USA.

7. The Radical Evangelical: Seeking a Place to Stand: By Nigel Wright. I loved this book, critical but constructive as the possibilities for evangelicalism in the future, with a UK and European focus.

And a few more, but I’ll stop there (and I’m not including Barna’s Revolution, I’ve already critiqued it here).


Tagged: , ,

Share on Facebook

8 comments


  1. Comment by Helen

    8.39 pm on 9 May 2008

    By the way I posted an interview with Christine Wicker on my blog this week, about her new book and her beliefs.


  2. Comment by Paul

    7.45 am on 10 May 2008

    Thanks Jase :)

    can i ask after all these books, what have you distilled down, the +ive and -ive? what critiques echoed with you and how have you responded to them in your own adaption and embrace of the evangelical tradition?

    a few more blog posts maybe for next time you do an evangelical week :)


    1. Comment by Jason

      7.48 am on 10 May 2008

      Now you’ve given me something to do next week :-) and the week after, and the week after that… ;-)


  3. Comment by Liam

    12.08 pm on 12 May 2008

    Jason, I enjoy your book lists, like the one you made in relation to philosophy and theology the other day. I wondered, do you keep an amazon list or any kind that I could look at? Liam


    1. Comment by Jason

      12.28 pm on 12 May 2008

      Hi Liam, sorry I don’t but I can email you my full bibliography :-)


  4. Pingback by Critiques of the Emerging Church at Jason Clark

    5.17 pm on 12 May 2008

    [...] the end of my week on evangelicalism, I wrote a post about the need to always critique whatever form of church we are most engaged with, and included a [...]


  5. Comment by Charlie Boyd

    10.44 am on 18 May 2008

    Evangelicalism is certainly a strange ‘beast’ in its many forms worldwide – its weakness though for a hurting world is it’s two core beliefs:

    1) Jesus (Yeshua) came to save all mankind by His atoning death on a Roman cross.

    2) Those who don’t ‘believe’ the message don’t get the salvation but are either eternally punished in ‘hell’ or extinguished.

    Evangelicals do not like talking about the inconsistencies in these two statements.How can a loving Father as depicted by Yeshua have planned these 2 events.

    This I believe is the reason most of the Western world will not embrace Evangelical Christianity.

    Before you eat me alive read I Timothy 4 verse 10 ( preferably in the Greek) and let me know your thoughts.


  6. Comment by bradm

    6.37 pm on 24 May 2008

    His name is Mark Noll.


Comments are now closed.